Written on: April 6, 2026
It’s safe to say that 2026 has been a roller-coaster so far for propane providers. Many parts of the country have contended with a memorably cold winter, increased gallons and operational pressures due to major weather events. All parts of the country have been dealing with recent challenges around rising prices due to global events and the Iran conflict. Add to that the omnipresent trials of regulations and labor shortages, and it’s unsurprising that many industry veterans are looking for ways to either cash out their ownership stake or to capitalize on the current buying opportunities.
But what does the buyer landscape look like right now for business owners looking to sell?
Well, it’s a markedly different market than it was a decade ago.
New Buyers, New Options for Sellers
The most significant major shift in the acquisitions environment has been the increase in private capital, which has filled a traditional bank lending gap for many propane providers and other lower middle market businesses.
Private lenders and equity providers have proven to be more nimble than traditional banks in their deal-making processes as credit availability has tightened in recent years. The result is not only more M&A activity but also an expanded menu of exit options for small business owners at various stages of their careers. Whether your primary concern is maximizing the price for your business or you have other priorities such as preservation of your company’s legacy or the best transition for your staff, the flexibility of a private capital partner can be advantageous.
Many sellers want liquidity, tax efficiency and a stake in future growth. In the current economic climate, strong, relationship-driven businesses are attracting many distinct types of buyers and often command higher values — so owners are starting these strategic conversations years in advance.
Stepping Away – But Not Out – with Rollover Equity
Financial buyers in today’s marketplace are less interested in slashing costs post-sale and are instead placing a premium on business continuity and experienced leadership. By drawing on the enduring relationships, employee expertise and established processes of an acquired propane company, they’re helping the business access capital for acquisitions and growth initiatives to reach new levels of profitability.
Sellers are more frequently offered the option to reinvest, or “roll,” a portion of their proceeds from a sale into an equity stake of the newly formed holding company. Historically, rollover equity was less common in the propane sector, but that’s changing fast. GF Data (an M&A data firm) reports that 63.6% of middle-market deals in 2024 included it, and many advisors estimate the deal rate of rolled equity is closer to 50% in financial buyer transactions within the lower middle market where the vast majority of propane distribution businesses reside. In short, the expanded interest of private financial buyers in the lower middle market has introduced creative exit options for small business owners.
For sellers, there’s a lot to like about a rollover equity arrangement, including the opportunity to profit from their business’s future growth. Rollover equity also makes it possible to defer taxes on part of the sale proceeds — and introduces the potential for tax-free gains through provisions like Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) under Section 1202 of the tax code. The seller may even continue earning a salary and/or bonuses after the sale in a continuing executive role.
For buyers, rollover equity has the considerable advantage of reducing the amount of outside capital needed to close, bridging valuation gaps and keeping both parties in the transaction aligned for continued growth.
How much of a stake can you retain in a rollover equity arrangement? Of course, it depends on the particular dynamics of the deal, but rollover stakes typically fall in the range of 20% to 40%.
What Works for Your Transition Plan?
If you’re considering selling your propane company or locating meaningful capital support for growth in the near future, the most appealing deal structure will depend on where you are in your career. For someone looking to fully embrace retirement, it may make sense to take the last dollar at closing. On the other hand, owners who envision themselves working in the propane space for years or decades to come can receive a lot of benefits from a partial cash-out combined with an ongoing minority ownership and a strong capital provider by their side.
You will also want to gain a clear sense of the buyer’s investment horizon. Independent sponsors and family offices (i.e., high net worth individuals with dedicated investing teams) tend to take a longer, more flexible approach, while more traditional private equity often works on a tighter timeline. Finding a financial buyer who understands the propane space — and aligns with your own timeline and desires — can make all the difference.
Selling a business you’ve spent many years building is a significant step. But in today’s M&A environment, it’s no longer an “all or nothing” decision. With an expanded variety of buyers, you have the opportunity to set up a deal that aligns with your goals, values and vision for the next chapter of your professional life.
Jeff Simpson is the founder and managing member of Notch Capital, a private investment firm specializing in buyouts and recapitalizations of lower middle market businesses in the propane and home services industries. Notch Capital also provides advisory services to help these businesses strengthen their performance and analyze acquisitions.