warm thoughts

NPGA FILES LAWSUIT: DENVER’S ELECTRIFICATION ORDINANCE; FILES BRIEF AGAINST DOE RULE

Written on: July 15, 2024

From the National Propane Gas Association Bobtail

LAWSUIT AGAINST DENVER’S ELECTRIFICATION ORDINANCE

On July 3, 2024, NPGA joined a diverse coalition including the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), the National Apartment Association (NAA), the National Restaurant Association (NRA), the Colorado Association of Home Builders (CAHB), and the American Hotel and Lodging Association (AHLA) in challenging Denver’s electrification ordinance. As we explained in our court filing, a federal law called the Energy Policy and Conservation (EPCA) preempts state and local laws governing the energy use and energy efficiency of products for which EPCA sets energy conservation standards, and the 2022 Denver Energy Code, that explicitly restricts the use of gas appliances, violates this federal law. This is the same legal theory under which the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, a federal appeals court governing several western states, invalidated the City of Berkeley’s electrification ordinance. NPGA has succeeded under this theory in supporting the repeal of electrification ordinances, including the City of Riverside earlier in June. NPGA continues to be involved in challenging electrification ordinances in New York and Washington States.

BRIEF AGAINST DOE APPLIANCE RULES

On Wednesday, July 10, NPGA and partner organizations filed a reply brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in an ongoing challenge against three United States Department of Energy (DOE) rules that would limit customer access to propane appliances. The challenged standards would, in violation of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA), eliminate from the market furnaces and commercial water heaters installed in millions of homes and businesses today. Our brief argues that these noncondensing propane appliances benefit consumers by having a performance characteristic that allows them to perform in their existing buildings without renovation, which the plain text of EPCA protects from elimination. Additionally, the brief argues that DOE rules do not follow statutory requirements and fail to meet the necessary legal standard of being technologically feasible and economically justified, and pulls from the recent groundbreaking Supreme Court decision overruling Chevron to argue that courts, not agencies, should handle technical statutory questions.

For more, contact NPGA General Counsel Benjamin Nussdorf at bnussdorf@npga.org or Associate General Counsel Kate Gaziano at kgaziano@npga.org